
What's on Her Mind? Reflections on the Mental Workload
In What's on Her Mind: The Mental Workload of Family Life, author and psychologist Allison Daminger explores something many women will recognise: the mental effort involved in managing the many demands of everyday life. While the title refers to a specific psychological concept, the book captures something much more familiar – the invisible strain of thinking, organising, anticipating and remembering all the things that need to be done.
For many women, life doesn't just feel busy; it can feel like a constant mental marathon. From managing household responsibilities and juggling careers to caring for others and keeping track of everyone's needs, there is often a great deal happening beneath the surface. Even when we're not physically doing anything, our minds can be occupied with what needs to happen next, what might have been forgotten and what still needs our attention.
And when that mental load becomes too heavy, stress, exhaustion and a persistent feeling of not doing enough can take hold.
Why this matters – especially for women
The idea of 'doing it all' is more than a cultural cliché. Women continue to shoulder a disproportionate share of household management and caring responsibilities, as well as much of the mental work involved in organising family life. This can include remembering appointments, anticipating needs, planning ahead and making sure everything runs smoothly.
The cognitive workload isn't simply about being busy. It's about the mental space occupied by responsibilities that can be difficult to put down, even when there is nothing immediate to do.
Looking beyond who does the work
One of the things I found particularly interesting about Daminger's research is that she looks beyond the practical tasks involved in running a household and examines the thinking that happens before, during and after those tasks.
She identifies four distinct elements of cognitive labour:
- Anticipating: recognising that something needs to be done, or foreseeing a potential problem.
- Identifying: working out the different ways of addressing that need.
- Deciding: choosing what to do.
- Monitoring: making sure it actually happens and dealing with anything that needs following up.
Take something as ordinary as organising a family holiday. There is the initial recognition that a holiday needs to be planned, researching destinations and accommodation, comparing options, making decisions, booking everything and then keeping track of all the arrangements. The actual holiday might be shared and enjoyed by everyone, but the thinking required to make it happen may have fallen largely to one person.
What makes Daminger's research particularly interesting is her finding that this cognitive work is not necessarily shared equally, even in couples who consider themselves to have an egalitarian relationship. Women often carry a greater share, particularly the anticipating and monitoring – the parts that are perhaps least visible to others.
This challenges the idea that household responsibilities can be measured simply by looking at who does the cooking, cleaning or school run. There is another layer of work that can go largely unnoticed: the responsibility for noticing what needs doing in the first place, working out how to do it and remembering to make sure it gets done.
When being responsible becomes part of who we are
Perhaps one of the more difficult aspects of the cognitive workload is that it can become so familiar that we stop questioning it. We simply assume that remembering, anticipating and organising are things we are supposed to do.
For some women, being the person who holds everything together becomes part of their identity. They know what everyone needs, notice what has been forgotten and think several steps ahead. They may even take pride in being capable and dependable.
But there can be a cost to this. It can become difficult to let go of responsibility, even when someone else is willing to take it on. Rest can feel uncomfortable. Asking for help can feel like another task to organise. And resentment can build, sometimes alongside guilt for feeling resentful at all.
There is also the question of what happens to our sense of ourselves when so much of our mental and emotional energy is directed outwards. How much space is left for our own thoughts, needs and ambitions?
The emotional cost of carrying so much
In counselling, women sometimes describe feeling exhausted, overwhelmed or irritable, but also struggling with a sense that they shouldn't feel this way. After all, they may have a good job, a family, a home and a life that looks perfectly manageable from the outside.
There can be a particular kind of guilt attached to feeling overwhelmed: the sense that other people manage perfectly well, or that if only we were better organised, more patient or more capable, things would feel different.
Sometimes frustration with a partner or family members sits alongside guilt for feeling frustrated. We might want others to take more responsibility, but find it difficult to explain exactly what needs doing, or to relinquish control over how it gets done.
This can leave us feeling both unsupported and responsible for keeping everything going.
And perhaps one of the most important questions is whether we have become so accustomed to attending to everyone else's needs that we've lost touch with our own.
A final reflection
Reading about the cognitive workload offers an opportunity to think about the invisible work that so many women carry, and how easily it can become accepted as simply part of everyday life.
It also invites us to look beyond the practical question of how responsibilities are divided and consider the emotional experience of carrying them. What does it mean to be the person everyone relies on? How difficult is it to step back from that role? And what might happen if we began to give our own needs the same attention we give to everyone else's?
Perhaps the starting point isn't necessarily to become better at managing everything, but to begin questioning why we feel responsible for so much in the first place.